A place for friends to meet... with reflections on politics, history, art, music, books, morals, manners, and matters of faith.
A blog by Elena Maria Vidal.
"She was not a guilty woman, neither was she a saint; she was an upright, charming woman, a little frivolous, somewhat impulsive, but always pure; she was a queen, at times ardent in her fancies for her favourites and thoughtless in her policy, but proud and full of energy; a thorough woman in her winsome ways and tenderness of heart, until she became a martyr."
"We have followed the history of Marie Antoinette with the greatest diligence and scrupulosity. We have lived in those times. We have talked with some of her friends and some of her enemies; we have read, certainly not all, but hundreds of the libels written against her; and we have, in short, examined her life with– if we may be allowed to say so of ourselves– something of the accuracy of contemporaries, the diligence of inquirers, and the impartiality of historians, all combined; and we feel it our duty to declare, in as a solemn a manner as literature admits of, our well-matured opinion that every reproach against the morals of the queen was a gross calumny– that she was, as we have said, one of the purest of human beings."
"It is now sixteen or seventeen years since I saw the queen of France, then dauphiness, at Versailles; and surely there never lighted on this orb, which she hardly seemed to touch, a more delightful vision. I saw her just above the horizon, decorating and cheering the elevated sphere she had just begun to move in, glittering like a morning star full of life and splendor and joy. Oh, what a revolution....Little did I dream that I should have lived to see such disasters fall upon her, in a nation of gallant men, in a nation of men of honor and of cavaliers! I thought ten thousand swords must have leaped from their scabbards, to avenge even a look which threatened her with insult. But the age of chivalry is gone; that of sophisters, economists, and calculators has succeeded...."
~Edmund Burke, October 1790
A Note on Reviews
Unless otherwise noted, any books I review on this blog I have either purchased or borrowed from the library, and I do not receive any compensation (monetary or in-kind) for the reviews.
The Queen was bone tired. She was led across the courtyard of the Palais de Justice to the Conciergerie and her damp, moldy cell. Yet in that hopeless place she had received much spiritual consolation. Two of her guards were devout Catholics, and earlier in the fall had permitted the holy, non-juring priest Abbé Magnin to twice hear her confession, and even once say Mass in her cell. She had been able to receive Holy Communion for the first time in more than a year. "Now you will have the strength to endure your torments," the Abbé said to her. The guards assisted at Mass with her. Two nights before the trial began, another non-juring priest secretly brought her Holy Communion. She knew it was her Viaticum.... ~fromTrianonby Elena Maria Vidal, Chapter Seven "The Sacrifice" Share
17 comments:
Anonymous
said...
I'm sure these two guards were taking a risk to bring a non-juring priest to the Queen and were willing to do so. A little light in a time of darkness. Ste. Chappelle is in the same area as the Palais de Justice and the Conciergerie.
Yes, they were taking a great risk. I think they were both arrested later on. Only Abbe Magnin survived to tell of the secret Mass. Yes, dear Elisa, the Sainte-Chapelle adjoins the Palias de Justice.
The painting seems to depict the Queen in almost Carmelite attire - is this from a Carmelite source, because she was close to the carmel, Am I correct?
I cannot believe how horribly her reputation has been distorted for all of history - and why on earth is Bastille Day a huge celebration?
Yes, Terry, Marie-Antoinette was a benefactress of the Carmelite order. Her husband's aunt was a Carmelite nun and is a Blessed of the Church, Madame Louise, as you probably know. The king and queen would visit her once a year at the Carmel of Saint Denis. What the queen is wearing in the picture is actually just plain old widows' weeds, what any woman at the time would wear when her husband passed away.
Yes, her reputation has been distorted beyond belief because people are still trying to justify the Revolution and its crimes. Bastille Day will be celebrated as long as people continue to celebrate the spirit of Revolt.
Did Abbe Mignon ever suffer for saying Mass/hearing confession? or did they leave him alone? If so, why?
After reading a lot over the past several months about the Revolution, I asked myself the same question about Bastille Day. Having lived in France and gone to school there, I never heard anyone question this or actually talk about how horrible this day was and what the implications were. And, we were always told, "It's the French version of our 4th of July".
The abbe was able to get away with it saying mass for the prisoners-- he was never discovered. There were many priests who ministered in the prisons of the Revolution, and some managed to elude the authorities. The abbe was already a prisoner there himself.
As with many secular holidays Bastille Day is based upon a myth and was invented by the authorities to replace the Christian fetes. There were only seven prisoners in the Bastille when it was stormed and were all living quite comfortably. No one talks about the REAL tyranny which followed when the supposed symbol of "tyranny" was torn down.
Oh, yes, because he would not take the oath to the government and deny the papal supremacy. All the non-juring priests were arrested and many guillotined or killed. Many were murdered in the September Massacres in 1792. Marie-Antoinette would only receive the sacraments from a non-juring priest.
Dear Paula, thank you so much for understanding. That is exactly why so much of my writing is devoted to Marie-Antoinette. Her life, her agony, her death was a prophetic moment of things to come, which is why I quoted the Book of Apocalypse so often in "Trianon." It is not just about her, it is about all of us, NOW.
Dear Elena, while reading your last posts it struck me that THIS (see our last comments) is the reasons of your books...The seeds planted by the French Revolution yielded poisoned fruits in the last century.
I like the quote below the picture of the Queen on your blog: it is so telling... The chivalry was really abolished in the era inaugurated by the Revolution.
I will return perhaps today to write one more comment. I am happy for our conversation.:-) Thank you for the delicious "tea".
Dear Elena, the suffering of the Queen and of those persecuted on one hand, the profiles of the tormentors on the other hand resemble so much what has happened in my old country, Romania when the communism was imposed...such a pity that the books that I read about the communist prisons of East-Europe (Romania in special) are not translated in English... I should consider posting on the topic. You inspired me.
It all ties in, Paula, it all ties in. Yes, the Communists were the heirs of the Jacobins. You should post about them, dear. Everyone talks about the Nazis but they forget the horrors of Communism....
Dear Elena, I actually consider to make a blog on the topic. Perhaps not very soon rather in few weeks/months. Here is almost 10 pm. Thank you for the having me as a guest, Elena.:-)
When I visited the Palais de Justice, I was the only visitor at that time and words cannot describe my feelings and emotions when I realised that now I am treading on history! Marie Antoinette Voges
Marie-Antoinette "en gaulle" by Elisabeth Vigée-Lebrun
#1 in Kindle Biographies of Royalty!
Marie-Antoinette, Daughter of the Caesars: Her Life, Her Times, Her Legacy
An Audible Bestseller
Marie-Antoinette, Daughter of the Caesars: Her Life, Her Times, Her Legacy
An Amazon Bestseller
Trianon: A Novel of Royal France
My Queen, My Love: A Novel of Henrietta Maria
Available from Amazon
The Saga of Marie-Antoinette's daughter, Marie-Thérèse of France
A Novel of the Restoration
In Kirkus Top 20 for 2014! And #1 in Kindle Historical Mystery, Thriller & Suspense Fiction
"In every Eden, there dwells a serpent . . . ."
#1 in Kindle History of France!
The Night's Dark Shade: A Novel of the Cathars
Listen to Tea at Trianon Radio
All about Marie-Antoinette!
Join me on Facebook!
Elena Maria Vidal Author Page
Join me on X!
@emvidal
Visit My Tumblr!
East of the Sun, West of the Moon
St. Teresa of Avila, pray for us!
"...Bud forth as the rose planted by the brooks of waters. Give ye a sweet odor as frankincense. Send forth flowers, as the lily...and bring forth leaves in grace, and praise with canticles, and bless the Lord in his works." —Ecclesiasticus 39:17-19
The fact that a link is provided here in no way constitutes an endorsement of everything on the other end of the link.
Comments Policy
Comments are moderated. If a comment is not published, it may be due to a technical error. At any rate, do not take offense; it is nothing personal. Slanderous comments will not be published. Anonymity may be tolerated, but politeness is required.
I would like to respond to every comment but my schedule renders it impossible to do so. Please know that I appreciate those who take the time to share their thoughts.
17 comments:
I'm sure these two guards were taking a risk to bring a non-juring priest to the Queen and were willing to do so. A little light in a time of darkness.
Ste. Chappelle is in the same area as the Palais de Justice and the Conciergerie.
Yes, they were taking a great risk. I think they were both arrested later on. Only Abbe Magnin survived to tell of the secret Mass. Yes, dear Elisa, the Sainte-Chapelle adjoins the Palias de Justice.
The painting seems to depict the Queen in almost Carmelite attire - is this from a Carmelite source, because she was close to the carmel, Am I correct?
I cannot believe how horribly her reputation has been distorted for all of history - and why on earth is Bastille Day a huge celebration?
Yes, Terry, Marie-Antoinette was a benefactress of the Carmelite order. Her husband's aunt was a Carmelite nun and is a Blessed of the Church, Madame Louise, as you probably know. The king and queen would visit her once a year at the Carmel of Saint Denis. What the queen is wearing in the picture is actually just plain old widows' weeds, what any woman at the time would wear when her husband passed away.
Yes, her reputation has been distorted beyond belief because people are still trying to justify the Revolution and its crimes. Bastille Day will be celebrated as long as people continue to celebrate the spirit of Revolt.
Did Abbe Mignon ever suffer for saying Mass/hearing confession? or did they leave him alone? If so, why?
After reading a lot over the past several months about the Revolution, I asked myself the same question about Bastille Day. Having lived in France and gone to school there, I never heard anyone question this or actually talk about how horrible this day was and what the implications were. And, we were always told, "It's the French version of our 4th of July".
The abbe was able to get away with it saying mass for the prisoners-- he was never discovered. There were many priests who ministered in the prisons of the Revolution, and some managed to elude the authorities. The abbe was already a prisoner there himself.
As with many secular holidays Bastille Day is based upon a myth and was invented by the authorities to replace the Christian fetes. There were only seven prisoners in the Bastille when it was stormed and were all living quite comfortably. No one talks about the REAL tyranny which followed when the supposed symbol of "tyranny" was torn down.
I didn't realize the Abbe was a PRISONER too.
Oh, yes, because he would not take the oath to the government and deny the papal supremacy. All the non-juring priests were arrested and many guillotined or killed. Many were murdered in the September Massacres in 1792. Marie-Antoinette would only receive the sacraments from a non-juring priest.
The French Revolution had a major contribution to what we call today the "culture of death".
The life of Marie-Antoinette is prophetic for the fate of many women in the times to come... Therefore her story should be better understood.
I am glad that you, Elena-Maria, have chosen this area.
Dear Paula, thank you so much for understanding. That is exactly why so much of my writing is devoted to Marie-Antoinette. Her life, her agony, her death was a prophetic moment of things to come, which is why I quoted the Book of Apocalypse so often in "Trianon." It is not just about her, it is about all of us, NOW.
Dear Elena, while reading your last posts it struck me that THIS (see our last comments) is the reasons of your books...The seeds planted by the French Revolution yielded poisoned fruits in the last century.
I like the quote below the picture of the Queen on your blog: it is so telling... The chivalry was really abolished in the era inaugurated by the Revolution.
I will return perhaps today to write one more comment.
I am happy for our conversation.:-)
Thank you for the delicious "tea".
You are welcome, Paula! I am happy for it, too!!
Dear Elena, the suffering of the Queen and of those persecuted on one hand, the profiles of the tormentors on the other hand resemble so much what has happened in my old country, Romania when the communism was imposed...such a pity that the books that I read about the communist prisons of East-Europe (Romania in special) are not translated in English... I should consider posting on the topic. You inspired me.
It all ties in, Paula, it all ties in. Yes, the Communists were the heirs of the Jacobins. You should post about them, dear. Everyone talks about the Nazis but they forget the horrors of Communism....
Dear Elena, I actually consider to make a blog on the topic.
Perhaps not very soon rather in few weeks/months.
Here is almost 10 pm. Thank you for the having me as a guest, Elena.:-)
Yes, Paula, there should be a blog on that topic! Our Lady of Fatima will guide you! You are a most welcome guest here, my dear.
When I visited the Palais de Justice, I was the only visitor at that time and words cannot describe my feelings and emotions when I realised that now I am treading on history!
Marie Antoinette Voges
Post a Comment