Monday, November 16, 2026

Montesquieu on the Nature and Sources of Law

 From Adriann Vermeule at The New Digest:

Motivation. Why should we care today what a French jurist of the middle of the 18th century thought about law? Well, one such reason is simple: if we think, with the classical jurists and canonists, that law has a real and enduring nature apart from the will of this or that sovereign lawmaker, then we very much ought to consult Montesquieu as an intelligent and profoundly learned guide to what that law is and what it requires. As we will see, Montesquieu himself argues forcefully and memorably that law has a real and enduring nature, and much of his book can be seen as an effort to disentangle the key distinction, originally offered by a Roman jurist named Gaius, between the law that is common to all mankind (ius gentium), and on the other hand the law that is particular to a given polity (ius civile).2

A second reason for caring what this 18th century French jurist wrote and thought is that our own American framers were profoundly influenced by Montesquieu, and by the classical understanding of law that permeates Montesquieu’s work. One might very plausibly argue that he was by many measures the leading influence upon the legal and constitutional thought of the whole founding era. Montesquieu, for example, is the single most cited jurist in the Federalist Papers by a large margin; he is quoted there eleven times, while the next closest, Blackstone, is quoted only three times, and John Locke not even once.3 And if we look at writings from the ratification debates overall, we get the following leader-board of citations: Montesquieu, 139 citations; Blackstone, 115 citations; John Adams, 56 citations; Locke, 40 citations.4 The framers and ratifiers were drunk on Montesquieu.5 Think of this the next time someone starts talking about “our Lockean founding.” Intellectually speaking, our founding was far more Montesquieuvian than Lockean.

Of course, the second reason I have given for caring what Montesquieu wrote is not mutually exclusive of the first. It is perfectly possible and indeed entirely sensible to believe both that law has a real and enduring nature apart from what positive law in this or that legal order may happen to command or prohibit, and also to care about what our own framers thought about law and what they specified in their constitutions and law codes. To the framers themselves, this combination would seem entirely natural, because they very much thought that law has a real and enduring nature apart from the will of this or that sovereign lawmaker. They took constitution-writing to be at least in part an act of discernment, the discovery and implementation of real, pre-existing legal duties and structures, as opposed to the willful creation of law. It’s hard to get our minds around that understanding, after we have been saturated with positivist legal theory since the 1960s, and reading Montesquieu is a fine corrective to the post-1960s theory. (Read more.)


Share

No comments: