From Unlicensed Punditry:
I was right about the atrocities disappearing from the front pages. I was wrong about communism having been defeated.
Fifteen years later, Marxism and its various ideological offspring are enjoying something of a renaissance, particularly among people who have never experienced the consequences of living under the systems they find so intellectually appealing. I think I understand why, although I didn’t recognize it in 2011.
To understand what happened, we need to consider a concept borrowed from the law: severability.
Severability means that certain provisions of a law, contract, or agreement can be separated from the whole without invalidating what remains. Legislators frequently write severability clauses into laws so that if some provision is struck down, the rest survives.
It is a useful legal concept, but it has some rather significant limitations when applied to history and civilization. Some things cannot be severed without fundamentally changing the nature of what remains.
I believe the remarkable survival of communism as a respectable political philosophy, despite its spectacular historical failures, is the result of an intellectual exercise in severability. We have managed to separate the promises of communism from its consequences, its theoretical appeal from its practical application, and ultimately, the ideology itself from the history that should have discredited it. (Read more.)


No comments:
Post a Comment