I just finished reading The Lives and Deaths of the Princesses of Hesse by Frances Welch. It clarified for me many things of which I had not been fully aware. The case of Mrs. Manahan aka "Anna Anderson" is described inaccurately but otherwise the historical research is superb. The deaths of two of the sisters in Russia is the central moment to which everything leads. After that the world is changed forever. Many details about Ella's final days I found deeply moving and so had to look for pictures. Ella or Elizabeth of Hesse, after becoming a widow when her husband Grand Duke Serge was blown up, established a active congregation of sisters to care for the poor and sick in Moscow, the first ever in Russia. In July of 1918 she was murdered by the Bolsheviks.
From Nicholas II:
The fact that Elizabeth Feodorovna was already dead when she fell into the mine is indicated by the position in which her body was found. Her body lay vertical, her arms folded over her body. If a living person falls down a depth of 15 metres (50 ft.), it would be impossible to fold ones arms so evenly.
It should also be noted that both hands of Elizabeth Feodorovna were tightly clenched, fingers bent, her nails sunk into the skin – this happens when a person is in severe pain.
In one hand, she clutched two laced bags containing some small items. Her head, eyes and nose were tied with a handkerchief folded in four layers. So, even if she remained alive in the mine, her position and the scarf on her face and head, from which she did not free herself, do not correspond to the version about bandaging the wounded grand duke.
All this speculation came about because Lubov Miller, who lived in Australia, came to Russia to work in the archives, but many archives were still closed at that time. The first edition of her book was published in 1988, therefore, she had no way of checking all the facts. (Read more.)
![]() |
St Elizabeth and Companions |