Anytime anyone takes their own life, I always suspect clinical depression no matter what they say their motives might be. From
Crisis:
The Christian mind has long rejected the possibility of suicide as a
good, ever since Augustine’s prominent discussion of it in the first
book of The City of God. In Chapter 22 of that
discussion, Augustine denies that men who commit suicide can ever be
admired for their greatness of soul. Given that Augustine’s prime task
was to write “against the pagans,” this line of argument is
understandable; he wants to discourage any admiration of individual
pagans. I would like to suggest that this restriction be revisited. A
Christian may admire the heights of pagan virtue without condoning its
sinful aspects. After all, Augustine’s firm condemnation of all things
pagan cannot be entirely reconciled with the Thomistic embrace of
pre-Christian Greek philosophy in the High Middle Ages. Admiring
Venner’s cause is not the same as condoning his self-annihilation.
Just maybe, there is something we can learn from the spirit of his
deed, if not from the deed itself. It certainly seems clear that Venner
did not mean for men of the West to follow his example and commit mass
suicide; he meant for it to shake them out of their malaise. It was a cri-du-cœur against the modern age.
Dominique Venner was, from my understanding, neither Catholic nor
formally pagan: his spiritual life was found in a kind of reverence for
the heritage of Europe; that heritage includes both pagan and Christian
religion, and so he admired both. His suicide in the cathedral was a
final act of respect, as well as a powerful setting for the message he
intended to convey. He saw the cathedrals of Europe as artistic
manifestations of the genius of his people. In his suicide note, “Reasons for a Voluntary Death,” he explained,
I am healthy in body and mind… However, in the evening of
my life, facing immense dangers to my French and European homeland, I
feel the duty to act as long as I still have strength. I believe it
necessary to sacrifice myself to break the lethargy that plagues us. I
give up what life remains to me in order to protest and to found. I chose a highly symbolic place, the Cathedral of Notre Dame de Paris, which I respect and admire:
she was built by the genius of my ancestors on the site of cults still
more ancient, recalling our immemorial origins. [Emphasis mine.]
Venner sees himself as the founder of something new, in defense of something old. (Read entire article.)
Share
2 comments:
I think you are right about the underlying cause of this or any suicide. How does descrating the cathedral demonstrate respect?
I agree. It was a sacrilegious act on many levels. One should not protest an evil by committing another act of evil.
Post a Comment