Friday, June 19, 2020

The Real Columbus

From USA Today:
What is lacking in the anti-Columbus narrative is any sense of history or of nuance. Columbus did something incredible reaching the Bahamas on board three small ships. The fleet's caravels were not warships but explorer vessels. He brought together two continents that didn’t know of one another’s existence. For the first time in history, the world acquired a truly global perspective.
 
We usually forget that people in the Middle Ages were deeply religious, much more than we are. This was certainly true of Columbus. Faith was his primary motivation. Those who now question Columbus conveniently ignore the fact that slavery, cannibalism, warfare and even human sacrifice all existed in the Americas before he even sailed. Even so, some today blame Columbus for everything they dislike in U.S. history, despite the ample evidence that he was a moderating force on his men, and the fact that he sought to keep good manners and friendly relations with Native Americans.  (Read more.)

From Dinesh D'Souza at First Things:
It is true that Columbus harbored strong prejudices about the peaceful islanders whom he misnamed “Indians”-he was prejudiced in their favor. For Columbus, they were “the handsomest men and the most beautiful women” he had ever encountered. He praised the generosity and lack of guile among the Tainos, contrasting their virtues with Spanish vices. He insisted that although they were without religion, they were not idolaters; he was confident that their conversion would come through gentle persuasion and not through force. The reason, he noted, is that Indians possess a high natural intelligence. There is no evidence that Columbus thought that Indians were congenitally or racially inferior to Europeans. Other explorers such as Pedro Alvares Cabral, Amerigo Vespucci, Ferdinand Magellan, and Walter Raleigh registered similar positive impressions about the new world they found.
So why did European attitudes toward the Indian, initially so favorable, subsequently change? Kirkpatrick Sale, Stephen Greenblatt, and others offer no explanation for the altered European perception. But the reason given by the explorers themselves is that Columbus and those who followed him came into sudden, unexpected, and gruesome contact with the customary practices of some other Indian tribes. While the first Indians that Columbus encountered were hospitable and friendly, other tribes enjoyed fully justified reputations for brutality and inhumanity. On his second voyage Columbus was horrified to discover that a number of the sailors he left behind had been killed and possibly eaten by the cannibalistic Arawaks.
Similarly, when Bernal Diaz arrived in Mexico with the swashbuckling army of Hernan Cortes, he and his fellow Spaniards were not shocked to witness slavery, the subjection of women, or brutal treatment of war captives; these were familiar enough practices among the conquistadors. But they were appalled at the magnitude of cannibalism and human sacrifice. As Diaz describes it, in an account generally corroborated by modern scholars:
They strike open the wretched Indian’s chest with flint knives and hastily tear out the palpitating heart which, with the blood, they present to the idols in whose name they have performed the sacrifice. Then they cut off the arms, thighs, and head, eating the arms and thighs at their ceremonial banquets. The head they hang up on a beam, and the body of the sacrificed man is not eaten but given to the beasts of prey.
(Read more.)
Share

9 comments:

Sansa said...

Hi Elena I like your blog.
I think it is sad that history is been twisted. Sadly Columbus is seen as nothing more be than a racists, imperialists and every evil thing.
The man was an explorer. The whole truth needs to be told.

elena maria vidal said...

Thanks! I agree!

julygirl said...

Am fed up with the USA and White race being blamed for all the evil that has transpired throughout history.

elena maria vidal said...

Me too. Tired of taking blame for things I had nothing to do with.

May said...

Pope Leo XIII wrote an encyclical on Columbus :
https://www.the-american-catholic.com/2019/10/12/pope-leo-xiii-on-columbus/

elena maria vidal said...

I didn't know, May! can't wait to read it! Thanks!!

Sansa said...

As a woman of color, I too am tired of one race (mainly white race) been blamed and potrayed as the villain.
I agree that there are some people can who are prejudiced and behave in a racists. This whole white people are to blame for every evil and is just so tiresome. It doesn't add anything constructive, except bring division.

elena maria vidal said...

I agree. People should not be lumped together and blamed collectively for anything.

julygirl said...

..unless they are men (LOL).